They had to have little to no medical comorbidity as measured by the Charlson Comorbidity Index (score = 0–33 higher = more comorbidity ), achieve at least an average score on a standardized intelligence test (i.e. By contrast, the nondemented controls were required to be cognitively intact. To ensure the accuracy of dementia versus control classification, this aim only used clock data from individuals who had been diagnosed with dementia via a memory disorder center consensus panel (behavioral neurologist, neurologist with specialty in movement disorders, neuropsychologist, geriatrician, social worker) and had met DSM-IV dementia criteria. The clock data were acquired from clinical charts (nonconsecutive manner) and from nondemented controls enrolled in research investigations with thorough cognitive screening. This aim used new clock sets from 231 individuals who had been diagnosed clinically with dementia as well as 50 nondemented controls. The second aim examined whether the clock criteria scores for the command condition alone could distinguish dementia patients from nondemented controls, as well as AD from frontal-subcortical dementia (PDD, VaD) subgroups. Due to the abbreviated MoCA scoring guidelines, we hypothesized that raters would find it more difficult to achieve adequate rater reliability with the MoCA scoring paradigm relative to the error scoring paradigm. For these reasons, our first study aim investigated novice rater intra- and interrater reliability for the MoCA clock scoring paradigm and the Cosentino et al. Like the MoCA clock drawing, however, novice clinician reliability for this in-depth error analysis has yet to be investigated. Templates and precise error definitions are used in order to reduce rater error. provide one error analysis approach based on cognitive theory and common dementia pathology. semantic, graphomotor, perseverative) informs clinicians about lesions/pathology. In stark contrast, clock scoring within the field of neuropsychology employs an analysis of errors, for error type (e.g. Thus, novice raters may have difficulty reliably scoring clocks. slight imperfection on closing the circle)’. ‘the clock face must be a circle with only minor distortion acceptable (e.g. Criteria appear open to interpretation, e.g. Likely to maximize clinical time, clock scoring criteria are basic with 1 point per clock contour, numbers and hands. Within the MoCA, clock drawing is one test item involving 3 of the total 30 points possible. Consider the modern dementia screening test, the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA ), which has gained popularity due to its clinical value over the Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE). This makes it difficult to accurately follow patients longitudinally for clinical change or to compare patient groups. Without assessing one’s reliability for test scoring, there is questionable validity. This should be a primary consideration when employing cognitive tests. Thus, when command and copy conditions are used together, clock drawing appears particularly helpful for differentiating dementia subtypes.įirst, clinicians using clock drawing rarely consider rater/scorer reliability. Alzheimer’s disease, AD) typically improve from command to copy. By contrast, individuals with less executive dysfunction relative to other domains of cognitive impairment (e.g. In dementia, poor command and copy performance is often seen among individuals with frontal system deficits like Parkinson’s disease with dementia (PDD) or Huntington’s disease. They present with an inability to improve in their drawing despite the presentation of a clock model errors from the command condition are transferred to the copy condition. Individuals with deficits in visuospatial and executive functions typically perform poorly on command and copy conditions. While the command condition requires numerous cognitive functions, the copy condition largely draws upon visuospatial and executive functions. On a separate sheet, patients then copy a predrawn clock model. As classically defined by Edith Kaplan (1988), clock test administration involves first commanding patients to ‘draw the face of a clock with all the numbers and set the two hands to 10 after 11’. Clock drawing is considered particularly beneficial for dementia assessment when both command and copy conditions are used and analyzed for errors.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |